If I could ask one thing while dying, I would ask everyone to read this book

Art of the Personal Essay

I’m reading a memoir I’ll be reviewing shortly – a book by a well-known author who led an interesting life, creatively and sexually, in New York in the 1960s and ’70s. I’m enjoying the book, but I’m not a reader of contemporary memoir, and I’m struck by the difference between this book and what I know as autobiography.

The only contemporary memoir I read before this one was James Salter’s Burning the Days, which was excellent. The other memoirs I know of are those whose authors were subsequently exposed as liars. And I never read them.

I have glanced through, on a dozen occasions, books of collected essays by fiction writers – efforts at cultural intellectualism to break the monotony (theirs and ours) of novel-writing, and found them to be hit or miss.

There have been a few observations and rants in this column about the novel’s irrelevance and the rise of nonfiction. Reading the book I am now, I can see what makes people so suspicious about these claims.

What I know as autobiography began with The Art of the Personal Essay, edited by Philip Lopate. I had never in my life considered nonfiction before buying this book, because I felt – I presumed – that fiction was a more worthy literary art form.

When I refer to things like courageous writing, I’m not referring to confessional or gossipy memoirs, or light recollections of an interesting period of one’s life: I’m talking about the best essays in Lopate’s anthology (note: avoid the last few). If you know somebody who wants to write, buy them this book for Christmas.

  • Share/Bookmark

2 Responses to “If I could ask one thing while dying, I would ask everyone to read this book”


  1. 1 Mick Halloran

    What’s your opinion of the Norton Book of Personal Essays?:

    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Norton-Book-Personal-Essays/dp/0393036545/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1260875951&sr=1-1

    It’s got some great pieces in it like Truman Capote’s Tangier.

  2. 2 SBA

    That book has a handful of good essays. I also like Flannery O’Connor’s “King of the Birds” and “Italian without a Master” by Mark Twain. So it’s worth buying. But I’d buy the Lopate first. Joseph Epstein, the editor of the Norton, seems to ask less of the essay, philosophically. His idea of an essay is closer to a short story, where much is shown and little directly stated. This can work in fiction but, I think, not in the essay.

    The introduction to the Norton is pretty good as well, but nothing like the Lopate introduction.

    If you want to teach yourself the essay and only have enough money for one book, I would unequivocally recommend the Lopate. But if you’re loaded, definitely buy both.

Comments are currently closed.